Richmond Hill Church Owners Plead Not Guilty in Historic Cemetery Case |
The owners of the former Headford United Church property on Leslie Street have pleaded not guilty to charges involving alleged damage to gravestones in the historic cemetery. |
The owners of a Richmond Hill church property have pleaded not guilty in a case involving alleged damage to gravestones at the historic Headford United Church Cemetery.
September 21 Inc., which owns the property at 9950 Leslie St., entered the not-guilty plea on Thursday, Sept. 10.
The property includes the former Headford United Church, which is now home to the Nativity of the Mother of God Ukrainian Orthodox Church.
The case centres on allegations that gravestones in the historic cemetery on the property were damaged.
The cemetery is part of the former Headford United Church site, giving the case particular significance because of the property's connection to Richmond Hill's local history.
With the owners pleading not guilty, the allegations remain before the court and have not been proven. The case will now continue through the legal process. |
32 Comments
Join the conversation
Good that this is going through the courts properly. These heritage sites need real protection and not just a slap on the wrist if something did happen.
September 21 Inc. Is kind of a strange name for a company that owns a church property. Anyone know the background on that?
Has anyone been out to see the cemetery recently? Wondering what condition the stones are actually in right now.
rhill_resident22I walked by there a few weeks ago actually. Some stones are really weathered but I couldn't tell what was natural aging versus something more recent. Would be curious to see an update too.
We don't have a current assessment of the cemetery's condition to share, but that would certainly be a meaningful follow-up as this case progresses through the courts.
Richmond Hill has so little left of its original history. Losing any piece of that cemetery would be devastating. Really hope the stones can be restored if they were damaged.
Glad they are taking this through the courts properly. These heritage sites need to be protected and people need to know there are consequences.
Tom BrecknerAgreed, though I hope the process moves quickly. Heritage sites can deteriorate fast and the longer this drags on the worse it could get.
Heritage site protection is a real concern in communities across the region, and court proceedings like this one are an important part of ensuring accountability.
September 21 Inc. Is the owner so they are ultimately responsible for what happens on that property right? Curious how this all unfolds.
Property ownership and legal responsibility are certainly central questions here, and those are exactly the kinds of issues the court process will work to address.
PatriciaF.That's usually how it works, yeah. Being the registered owner puts you on the hook for what happens on the land. But the details matter a lot in these cases.
9950 Leslie is right near where I drive every day. Never even noticed there was a cemetery back there. Kind of sad really.
It's a reminder of how much local history can be quietly tucked away on familiar streets, the Headford site's connection to Richmond Hill's past is a big part of why this case matters.
mike_rhillSame, I've driven past that stretch of Leslie tons of times and had no idea. Worth pulling over and taking a look sometime, there's actually quite a bit of local history tucked away along that road.
Headford Cemetery has graves going back to the 1800s. Damage to stones like that is basically irreplaceable. Once they are gone they are gone.
localhistoryguyThis is what people don't always get. You can't just replace a gravestone from the 1840s. The history is physically in that stone and once it's broken it's broken.
You raise a deeply important point, historic gravestones are irreplaceable records of a community's past, which is precisely why this case carries such particular significance for Richmond Hill's local history.
Not guilty plea does not mean much at this stage. The process just started. Lets see what actually comes out in court before anyone jumps to conclusions.
The Ukrainian Orthodox Church has been using that building for years. Hard to imagine they would want to cause any damage to the property they worship at.
That's a fair observation, and it's worth noting that the allegations are against September 21 Inc. As the property owner, the not-guilty plea means nothing has been proven in court at this stage.
Sandra KowalskiThat was my thought too. The congregation there has always seemed to take good care of the place. Hopefully the court process gives a clearer picture of what actually happened.
The Ukrainian Orthodox congregation has been there for years. I hope they are not being blamed unfairly before anything is even proven. The article says not guilty for a reason.
My great grandmother is buried in that cemetery. This whole situation has been really upsetting for our family. Those stones matter to a lot of people.
Not guilty plea so lets see how this plays out in court. Innocent until proven guilty and all that.
DaveM_RHExactly. People jump to conclusions way too fast on stuff like this. Let the court do its job.
Exactly right, as we noted in the article, the allegations have not been proven, and the case will now continue through the legal process.
I drive past 9950 Leslie all the time. Never knew there was a historic cemetery back there. Kind of wild that most people probably have no idea.
That cemetery has been there for well over a century. If those stones were actually damaged it would be a real shame. Hoping the court gets to the bottom of it.
I grew up near Headford United and that cemetery has been there forever. Some of those stones are really old. Really hope this gets sorted out properly.
Barb T.I remember my dad pointing out some of those stones when I was a kid. A few of the names on them are the same as street names around Richmond Hill, which tells you how far back some of those families go.
The cemetery's deep roots in the community are exactly what make this case so meaningful locally, and we'll continue following proceedings as they unfold.